Barbara van den Hoofdakker
Impact of ADHD on parents / grandparents / carers at home and in schools
ADHD can present significant challenges for parents, carers and teachers, affecting everyday interactions and relationships at home and in school. This webinar explores the emotional and practical impact of these challenges, including stress, reduced confidence and recurring conflicts, and examines how ADHD can influence relationships between children and the adults who support them.
Speaker: Prof. Barbara van den Hoofdakker (Accare Child Study Center / University of Groningen / University Medical Center Groningen, the Netherlands; PAINT Research Consortium)
Moderator: Barbara
[00:00:00] Prof. Barbara van den Hoofdakker: Welcome everyone, and good morning, good afternoon or good evening, depending on where you're joining from. Thank you, Barbara, for your nice introduction, and thank you all very much for being here. I'm happy to see so many people joining this webinar; although I cannot see you, I know many people are joining. When we talk about ADHD, we usually talk about the child: the behaviours, the diagnosis, the aetiology, the treatment. But today I would like to focus on the adults who live and work with these children every day: parents and teachers. What is their daily experience like? What happens in their interactions with the child? And perhaps most important for many of you: how can we as professionals talk with them in a way that helps them?
[00:01:00] First my disclosure slide, then something about the outline of this webinar. In the first part, I will look at the everyday experience of parents of children with ADHD. I will talk about their stress, their confidence as parents, about courtesy stigma, about their parenting practices and about what happens in their interactions with their child. In the second part I will do the same for teachers. In the third part I will bring this together and discuss that the difficulties in the interactions between these adults and children most likely run in both directions. And in the final part, I will discuss what the presented knowledge means for how we as professionals talk with parents and teachers. I will end with a few take-home messages. The next webinar will focus on behavioural interventions, so along the way I will already point out some links to that topic.
[00:02:19] Before we start with the first part, let me share with you the central idea that runs through my webinar. ADHD is something that becomes visible in the interaction with the environment. What we know about children with ADHD is that their behaviour is highly sensitive to context. Today I will focus on important adults in this context: parents and teachers. ADHD behaviour shows up at the breakfast table, during homework, in the middle of a maths lesson. And it's not only that the child influences the adults; the adults also influence the child. Understanding this two-way process, and the uncertainty about what causes what, is in my view of great importance to working constructively with families and schools.
[00:03:23] Imagine an ordinary school morning. A mother asks her eight-year-old son to get dressed. Five minutes later he is still in his pyjamas, absorbed in a toy. She asks again, a little louder, to get dressed. He says "yes, yes", but he does not move at all. The third time she's angry, and he shouts back. His younger sister starts to cry. They all leave the house late, and the mother arrives at work already exhausted. For many parents of children with ADHD, this is not an exceptional morning. It is a pattern that repeats itself at breakfast, during homework, at bedtime, during family visits and in the supermarket. Maybe you recognise this from the families you work with?
[00:04:20] So what distinguishes parents of children with ADHD from parents of other children? Let us look at what research tells us about that. A first theme is parenting stress. It is well established that parents of children with ADHD experience considerable stress. They report clearly more stress than parents of children without ADHD, and that stress increases with the severity of the child's ADHD behaviours. Stress is especially high when the child has conduct problems, which is quite common in children with ADHD, and when the parent has depressive symptoms, which is also very common, because these parents have an elevated risk of depression. These are all complicating factors that make stress even more severe. Stress matters not only because it is unpleasant: a stressed parent has less patience, less energy and less room to respond calmly. And that in turn affects the way the parent responds to the child.
[00:05:51] So that's an important thing to know. Let's go to a second theme, and that's parenting self-efficacy: the parent's confidence in his or her ability to raise the child well and to handle difficult situations. Many parents of children with ADHD gradually lose this confidence; this is a recurring and very well-established finding. Parents have tried kindness and strictness, rewards and punishments, and nothing seems to work for long.
[00:06:34] A third theme is stigma. On top of daily difficulties, parents often face judgement from others who see the child's behaviour, for example, as the result of poor parenting. This is also known as courtesy stigma: family members are judged negatively simply because they are connected to someone with ADHD. Parents may respond to this kind of stigma with shame or withdrawal, or they may avoid seeking help. So, to summarise the differences between parents of children with ADHD and parents of other children: parents of children with ADHD may experience more stress, lower parenting confidence and stronger feelings of being stigmatised.
[00:07:29] How do these differences show up in the everyday interactions between parent and child? Observational studies show a quite consistent picture. Children with ADHD comply less with requests, are more often oppositional, and find it harder to complete what is being asked of them. Their parents, in turn, give more commands and more corrections, react more negatively, and respond positively to their child less often. These differences in parenting between families of children with and without ADHD were confirmed in a very recent meta-analysis, which showed that on average, parents of children with ADHD show somewhat less responsiveness, warmth and encouragement, while they also show more abuse, including harsh punishment, interparental conflict and hostility. The differences were small to moderate and appear to be similar across very different cultures. That's also an important thing to mention. However, it is important to keep in mind that these studies were cross-sectional. The findings tell us that parenting differs, but not why. A child's ADHD behaviour may evoke these parental reactions, just as parental reactions may shape the child's behaviour.
[00:09:23] To go back to the example of the mother who tries to get her child ready for school: how can a simple request like getting dressed so easily turn into a battle? Very helpful in this respect is a model that was developed by Patterson already in 1982, who describes how interactions can escalate into what he called the coercive cycle. This model is based on operant conditioning, which basically tells us that behaviour that is followed by something pleasant becomes more likely to happen again. So let me explain the model. A parent gives an instruction or says no. The child does not comply. The parent repeats it louder. The child protests, which escalates into a tantrum. If the parent then escalates and yells or hits the child, and the child gives in, the parent learns that yelling or hitting works, while the child learns that giving in makes the yelling or hitting stop. So they both learn something. But if the parent gives in, the child will learn that the tantrum works, and the parent will learn that giving in stops the tantrum. So in both cases, parents and children have learned something that makes the next conflict more likely and more intense. In learning terms, both are negatively reinforced: their behaviour is rewarded because something unpleasant stops. Over time, the relationship can become dominated by conflict and corrections, while positive moments become rare. This is also where behavioural parent training comes in. It helps parents to step out of this cycle, for example by giving clear instructions, following through calmly and paying much more attention to positive behaviour. In the next webinar you will hear much more about this.
[00:11:47] But does this mean that every parent reacts in the same way to a child with ADHD? Not necessarily. Much also depends on the parent. How parent and child get along also depends on how well they fit together. The same child behaviour can lead to quite different interactions depending on the adults. For example, if the parent also has ADHD, which is not uncommon in families of children with ADHD, it is quite easy to imagine that this parent reacts differently to a child's behaviour than a parent without ADHD. So remember: the fit between parent and child characteristics is important when it comes to raising a child.
[00:12:43] Now let us move to the second part of this webinar: the teachers. Imagine a teacher with 40 children explaining a maths problem on the board. One boy taps his pencil, gets up to sharpen it for the third time, chats with his neighbour and then calls out the answer before anyone else has had a chance to think about it. The class laughs. The flow of the lesson is broken, and the teacher corrects him once again. By the end of the morning, she has said his name a dozen times, almost always in a negative tone. In many schools, this teacher works with large classes, limited materials, little or no training about ADHD, and a very, very high workload. Just as with parents, we can ask: in what respect does teaching children with ADHD differ from teaching other children?
[00:13:52] So let us start again with stress, but now teacher stress. [Brief technical interruption.] Teachers do experience stress, and children with ADHD are rated as considerably more stressful to teach than their classmates, particularly when they also show oppositional or aggressive behaviour or serious social difficulties, which are all quite common in children with ADHD. It is also known that this teacher stress is highly individual: it depends on the specific combination of teacher and child. This is quite easy to imagine, as ADHD behaviours tend to be more visible during long, unstructured or repetitive tasks, and less so when there is a clear structure, when there is frequent feedback and when the activity interests the child. So the school context, including the teacher's approach, influences ADHD behaviour in classroom settings. As with parents, it is about the fit between this child, this teacher and this classroom. I think you will all recognise that the same child may function quite differently with one teacher than with another, and, as we discussed earlier, may function differently with one parent than with the other.
[00:15:41] Another theme is again knowledge and self-efficacy. Do teachers believe that they can handle this child? Many teachers feel unprepared or insufficiently prepared to teach children with ADHD, which undermines their confidence that they can manage the class and help this specific child learn. We know that teacher knowledge varies widely, and studies worldwide, including studies from countries such as Ethiopia, Nigeria and South Africa, show that there are still persistent misconceptions, such as that ADHD is caused by poor parenting or by laziness of the child. So when teachers feel stressed and insufficiently equipped and have misperceptions, what is their relationship with the child like? Let's have a look at that.
[00:16:52] As we all know, a positive relationship with the teacher is important for every child, and possibly even more so for children with ADHD. Yet this relationship is often under strain. Children with ADHD feel less close to their teachers than their peers do. And teachers report this in the same way: they also feel less close to children with ADHD. Teachers also report more conflict and less cooperation with these children. A large meta-analysis showed that the more ADHD behaviour children display, the more conflict there is in their relationship with the teacher, especially when the behaviour is hyperactive. This matters because classmates notice when a child is always in trouble, and a poor relationship with the teacher is a risk factor for peer rejection and low self-esteem. So this relationship is of great importance. Here, too, it's important to mention that these data cannot show what causes what. The associations are most likely bidirectional.
[00:18:24] So let's have a look at what these conflicts actually look like in everyday classroom interactions. One study of my group illustrates what happens in daily classroom interactions. In that study, we observed children with ADHD and typically developing children from 6 to 12 years old in their own classrooms, and we recorded how much positive and corrective feedback each child received from the teacher. Here we see that the children with ADHD received considerably more corrective feedback than their classmates, and they also received more corrections than praise, whereas for typically developing children the balance was the other way around: they received more praise than corrections. There was also an encouraging finding. We found that when teachers experienced a close relationship with the child, the link between the child's hyperactivity and the teacher's corrections was weaker. So the positive relationship buffered this effect a bit. Here again, you see the importance of this relationship.
[00:19:52] So think about one child with ADHD. How often do you think this child hears something positive during the school day, and how often something negative? At school we can see the same type of escalating cycles that we saw at home. The child disrupts, the teacher corrects, the child becomes frustrated, the teacher becomes more stressed and corrects sooner. And why does this pattern keep repeating itself, even if nobody wants it to?
[00:20:29] So here we are again at the coercive cycle, but now in the classroom. When the teacher reprimands the child, the child receives attention, often in front of the whole class. For some children, that attention in itself rewards the disruptive behaviour, which may lead to continued disruption. The teacher may then intensify the correction, which makes the child stop, and in that case the teacher is rewarded because the disruption ends. So the teacher learns that correcting firmly works and will correct firmly even sooner next time. The child is also rewarded, as the aversive stimulus, the firm correction, stops. But it may also be that the cycle continues and leads to an escalation. The teacher may then, for example, and many teachers do this, give the child a time-out, which is usually rewarding for the teacher, because the disruptive child is not in the classroom anymore, and sometimes also for the child, for example when it leads to avoidance of an unpleasant or boring task. Meanwhile, the moments when the child is working quietly often go unnoticed, because that is exactly when the teacher can finally attend to the rest of the class. As a result, disruptive behaviour receives a lot of attention and positive behaviour very little. So again: who's influencing whom here? Does the child provoke the teacher, or does the teacher's reaction shape the child?
[00:22:15] This question brings me to part 3 of this webinar: who influences whom? When parents or teachers struggle with a child, a question that is often asked is: whose fault is this? Is the child difficult because the parents are too harsh or too lenient? Is the teacher not strict enough? Or is it all in the child? Research shows that this question is usually the wrong one, because influence most likely runs in both directions. For example, in an old study where hyperactive boys received stimulant medication or placebo, it was shown that the boys who received the stimulant medication complied more with their mother's instructions, and the mothers, who were blind to the treatment condition, gave fewer commands to their child in return. In another study, parents had to interact with boys they did not know, who had been trained to behave either like a typical child or like a child with ADHD and oppositional behaviour. After interacting with a difficult child, parents reported more anxiety, depressed mood and hostility, and felt less competent as parents. And remember, these were not even their own children. So apparently the behaviour of a child with ADHD can in itself cause stress and feelings of inadequacy in any adult.
[00:23:54] So children influence the adults around them. But at the same time, adults' reactions also shape the child's behaviour. We can derive that from the findings of a large body of behavioural parent training studies, in which we change the behaviour of the parents and see that the child's behaviour also changes. But also, for example, from a longitudinal study in which children were followed from ages three to six. It was demonstrated that over-reactive parenting and maternal stress predicted more ADHD symptoms later on, while children's ADHD symptoms predicted more maternal stress and depressive symptoms and less warmth later on. So both directions were present at the same time. The most accurate answer to the question "who started it?" is: we usually do not know, and it does not matter very much. What matters is that both sides are caught in a pattern that neither of them wants, and that a change on either side can help to break it.
[00:25:07] This is also the core idea behind behavioural parent training and behavioural teacher training. When adults learn to behave differently, for example with clear instructions, more attention for positive behaviour and calmer, more predictable responses to misbehaviour, the cycle can turn in a more positive direction. It can be difficult to explain this to parents, but it's very important: changing the adult's response is not an admission of guilt; it is simply the part of the cycle that is easiest to influence. As I told you, the next webinar will go into this in more detail. But if influence is probably bidirectional and the causes of interaction problems are often unclear, then what explanations do parents and teachers have about the cause of the child's behaviour, and why does that matter?
[00:26:13] Adults indeed have their own answers to the question: what causes ADHD behaviour and behaviour problems? And what adults believe about the cause of their child's behaviour influences how they react to it. Parents who see misbehaviour as intentional and under the child's control tend to react with more anger and harsher discipline. Parents who see it as less intentional tend to respond more calmly. Adults also form explanations about themselves. A parent who believes "this is my fault" may feel guilt and helplessness, and a teacher who believes "this is my fault" may disengage, or believe that the parents are the problem. This is also a very common belief of teachers. As professionals, we play an important role in which explanations people adopt. And that brings me to the fourth and final part of this webinar: how can we talk with parents and teachers in a way that relieves blame instead of adding to it?
[00:27:39] Parents and teachers are not to blame. They are part of the interaction, and they can be part of the solution. But that is something quite different from being the cause. Many parents and teachers have a sense of failure or already feel accused, and how we talk with them can either reinforce that feeling or relieve it, which is essential for motivating them to change their own behaviour. I will sum up a few things that may be important when talking to parents and teachers.
[00:28:18] First, explain to parents and teachers that influence runs in both directions and that we usually cannot say what causes what. For example, you could say: "When a child is very impulsive and frequently gets into dangerous situations, any parent would feel stressed. And when stress goes up, we all react more sharply, and children react to that again. That is not your fault, and it is not your child's fault. It is a pattern you are both stuck in, and patterns can change." Second, be careful in presenting research findings. For example, if you say "studies show that conflict is more common in families and classrooms with a child with ADHD", that normalises people's experience, while if you say "parents of children with ADHD are less warm", parents can easily hear this as an accusation. And third, not blaming also means taking seriously what parents and teachers tell us.
[00:29:30] And where does this start? Already in the diagnostic process. In the diagnostic process, it's important to consider parents and teachers not only as informants about the child's behaviour; their own experiences are part of the diagnostic assessment as well. So ask them: How do mornings and lessons actually go? How do conflicts occur? How stressed do you feel? How confident do you feel? What have you already tried? It is also a moment to ask gently and without assumptions how conflicts are handled, because we know that harsh and physical punishment is more common in these families, and the child's safety comes first. But you have to ask this in a very gentle way, without assumptions, as I said, because these are very delicate topics for parents. It is also the time to ask how they themselves explain the child's behaviour. This may vary a lot: they may see it as a disease, as something spiritual, as something medical, or as something like laziness. So it's really important to know what explanations parents or teachers themselves have.
[00:31:10] When they share their experiences, they often also share feelings and reactions they are not so proud of. So how should we respond to those? Many parents and teachers feel irritation, anger or exhaustion, and sometimes there are moments when they don't like the child. This can also occur, and it's good if the conversation [unclear] is open, so that they can talk honestly about this. They may also feel guilty because they have shouted or punished more harshly than they wanted to. These feelings and parenting behaviours are understandable, as the behaviour of a child with ADHD can trigger stress and hostility in any adult. But the most important thing is to validate these feelings: "It's completely understandable that you sometimes feel angry. Many parents and teachers in your situation would do so." And keep in mind that validating is not the same as approving harmful behaviour. It creates the safety people need to talk honestly about what happens, and that honesty is the starting point for change.
[00:32:39] And what can we offer when it comes to changing interaction patterns? Well, when interactions have become stuck in negative coercive cycles, behavioural parent or teacher training is an evidence-based next step. How you introduce these interventions also matters a lot. Present them not as a correction of poor parenting or poor teaching, but tell parents and teachers that it is something in which they learn specific skills for a child who needs more than the average child. Say, for example: "Your child needs more structure and more positive feedback than most children. Any parent would need extra tools for that." Explain also that supporting the adult is the same as supporting the child. Build on strengths that they already have – there are always things that parents and teachers already do well – and always start with small, achievable steps to change. And be clear about expectations. We know that it's very important that parents have positive expectations of the treatment they are going to receive. So they should be well informed about the evidence for the intervention, but also about what they can and cannot expect from it in terms of outcomes. In the next webinar, we'll discuss these interventions in more detail.
[00:34:33] This brings me to the end of this webinar. What would I like you to take home from today? First: try not to blame parents or teachers. Interactions are complex and causal relations are unknown. Second: include their experiences already in the diagnostic process. Talk about their stress, about their confidence, about interaction patterns and about their explanations of the cause of ADHD. Third: validate negative behaviours, feelings and thoughts. This really helps to have an open and honest conversation. And the last one: motivate them for behavioural training when interaction patterns become difficult or harmful. If you would remember only one sentence from today, then let it be something like: parents and teachers are not the cause of the child's problems, but they can be an important part of the solution, especially when we as professionals stand beside them. Thank you very much for your attention, and I'm looking forward to hearing your questions.
[00:36:08] Barbara (moderator): Thank you so much, Barbara. This was really, really great. Thank you.
Barbara van den Hoofdakker works as a clinical psychologist and professor at Accare Child Study Center and the department of Clinical Psychology and Experimental Psychopathology of the University of Groningen. Her research and clinical work focus on the treatment of children with behavioral difficulties, including children with ADHD.
Back to Webinar Library
